Article:
Approval provisions are commonplace in development agreements. Under option and promotion agreements, planning strategies, applications, variations and other important steps may require landowner approval before a developer or promoter can proceed.
The recent High Court decision in Persimmon Homes Limited v Harding Estates (East Anglia) Limited & Anor [2026] EWHC 2481 (Ch) reminds us that keeping someone informed is not the same as seeking their approval.
What happened?
In 2021 Persimmon acquired land from Harding Estates for £9.785m, with outline planning permission for up to 297 homes. The sale agreement required Persimmon to complete specified infrastructure and drainage works, including a new A120 roundabout and spine road and procure practical completion within two years of completion.
The agreement contained specific provisions relating to attenuation ponds. Persimmon could not agree the location of a pond without Harding Estates’ approval.
Importantly, the agreement also contained a structured approval procedure. Harding Estates had five working days to respond to a request. If it did not respond, Persimmon could make a further request. A further five working days without a response would result in deemed approval.
Persimmon subsequently proposed relocating an attenuation pond to a location affecting Harding Estates’ retained land. Between March 2022 and October 2023, it sent four emails containing progress updates, links to drawings and invitations for questions or comments. Neither the emails nor their subject lines mentioned the attenuation pond. Its proposed location was instead apparent from the linked drawings.
Persimmon argued that these communications were requests for approval and that Harding Estates had unreasonably withheld or delayed approval by failing to respond.
The High Court disagreed.
The emails’ stated purpose was to provide updates and invite comments. They were not requests for approval of the pond’s relocation. Providing drawings which happened to show the proposed new location did not turn an update into a contractual approval request.
The existence of the agreement’s formal approval procedure reinforced that conclusion. To trigger it, Persimmon needed to make an express written request identifying the approval sought.
There was a further problem for Persimmon. The Court also found that it had no realistic prospect of demonstrating that Harding Estates’ conduct had caused its failure to procure practical completion on time. Contemporary correspondence pointed instead to delay arising from the Highway Authority’s technical approval process.
Harding Estates therefore obtained summary judgment for Persimmon’s failure to reach practical completion within the contractual period.
What does this mean for strategic land agreements?
Distinguish approval, consultation and notification
The agreement should make clear which matters require landowners’ approval and which require only consultation or notification.
Correspondence should reflect that distinction.
Make an approval request unmistakable
Where contractual approval is required, say so expressly:
“This is a formal request for approval pursuant to clause [X] of the Agreement.”
Identify precisely the approval sought, attach relevant plans or documents, specify the contractual response deadline and follow any specified notice procedure.
Follow the deemed approval procedure
A deemed-approval provision can protect a promoter or developer against delay, but only if the contractual steps are followed.
Persimmon’s agreement already contained a deemed-approval mechanism. The problem was that Persimmon had not made the initial request correctly nor followed the prescribed process. Relying on Harding’s silence was not enough.
The agreement should clearly specify how to request approval, the response period, any further notice required if no response is received and when approval is deemed given.
Be clear about the grounds for withholding approval
Consider whether approval is at the landowner’s absolute discretion or must not be unreasonably withheld or delayed. Set out any agreed grounds for refusal.
Check approval procedures against other contractual requirements
Approval clauses should not be drafted in isolation. They must work with planning obligations, developer/promoter covenants, longstop dates and extension-of-time provisions.
The agreement should identify both the event triggering additional time and how the extension is calculated.
Keep evidence
A failure to respond to an approval request does not necessarily establish an entitlement to extra time.
If a developer or promoter considers that a landowner’s failure to respond is delaying the project, it should record this contemporaneously and retain evidence of the effect on the critical path. Correspondence attributing delay to a planning authority, utility provider or another third party may make a later case against the landowner harder.
Practical lessons for landowners
Landowners should understand the approval procedure and have reliable arrangements for handling requests, including:
- Monitoring the email addresses and contact details specified in the agreement;
- Passing requests promptly to the appropriate legal, technical and commercial advisers;
- Diarising response deadlines immediately; and
- Ensuring personnel changes do not cause contractual correspondence to be overlooked.
This is especially important where an agreement provides for deemed approval. Failure to identify and respond to a valid request may result in automatic approval potentially affecting retained land, access arrangements or the future development of the wider site.
Key points
The message from Persimmon is clear: do not leave the status of an approval request open to interpretation.
Promoters and developers should make approval requests explicit and follow the agreement’s notice and deemed-approval procedures carefully.
Landowners should recognise when the response period starts and ends and clearly record any approval, refusal or request for further information.
When drafting option and promotion agreements, stress test approval provisions with five questions:
- What requires approval?
- How must it be requested?
- How long does the landowner have to respond?
- On what grounds can approval be withheld?
- What happens if there is no response?
Clear drafting, followed by disciplined use of the contractual procedures can prevent an unanswered email from becoming a much more expensive dispute.
This article is for general information only and does not, and is not intended to, amount to legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. If you have any questions relating to your particular circumstances, you should seek independent legal advice.