Authors
Authors
Article:
Choosing a new brand is usually driven by marketing considerations. Is it memorable? Does it say something about the business? Will consumers understand it?
There is often a tension between a name that communicates what a business does and one that provides strong legal protection. The closer a brand comes to describing the goods or services being offered, the more difficult it can become to register and enforce as a trade mark. The case of Flowerbx Limited v Flowers Box London Limited provides a useful illustration of where that line can fall.
The FLOWERBX case
FLOWERBX operates an online flower delivery business under the FLOWERBX brand. The company obtained a UK trade mark registration for FLOWERBX covering various goods and services in 2017.
FLOWERBX brought proceedings against a competing flower business using FLOWERS BOX, FLOWERSBOX and FLOWERS BOX LONDON, alleging trade mark infringement under sections 10(2) and 10(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1994.
The defendant challenged the validity of the FLOWERBX registration. Part of their argument was that the mark was descriptive of the goods and services being offered.
FLOWERBX is clearly suggestive of the words “flower box”. The court therefore had to consider if the removal of the letter ‘o’ was enough to turn what was otherwise a descriptive name into a distinctive trade mark.
Can unusual spelling make a descriptive term distinctive?
Trade mark law generally prevents businesses from monopolising words that other traders may legitimately need to describe their products or services.
Changing the spelling of an ordinary expression does not automatically avoid that problem. If consumers would still perceive an altered word as simply describing a characteristic of the relevant products, an unusual spelling may not be enough to make it registrable.
That distinction is important for businesses considering deliberately abbreviated or unusual brand names. Removing vowels, joining words together or using a digital-style spelling may make a name more memorable, but it does not necessarily create a strong trade mark.
In FLOWERBX, the court considered how the average consumer would perceive the mark as a whole and in the context of the particular goods and services for which it was registered. The defendant’s descriptiveness attack ultimately failed.
What your trade mark covers is important
One of the useful reminders from FLOWERBX is that the analysis does not take place in the abstract. The question is not whether a word has a descriptive meaning, but whether the mark is descriptive in relation to the particular goods or services for which protection is sought.
That makes the specification of goods and services in a trade mark application more important. A business may be tempted to seek very wide protection if its plans are still developing, but the specification should only reflect the protection that the business may realistically need to enforce.
Can you strengthen your trade mark?
As well as arguing that the trade mark FLOWERBX was inherently distinctive, Flowerbx relied on the distinctiveness it had built through use and promotion of the brand.
The court considered evidence including company turnover, the extent of advertising (for example, on London buses and London Underground platforms) and marketing expenditure, press coverage in publications (including Vogue and The Telegraph) and social media presence. It concluded that FLOWERBX had acquired enhanced distinctiveness by early 2019.
In assessing whether consumers were likely to confuse FLOWERBX with the defendant’s signs (and therefore the mark was infringed), the court looked at the mark’s enhanced distinctive character. It is a useful reminder that a trade mark’s strength is not fixed at registration. Investment into and recognition of a mark may strengthen its distinctive character and enforceability.
A suggestive mark can still be valuable
FLOWERBX successfully enforced its rights. The court found infringement, including a likelihood of confusion between FLOWERBX and the signs used by the defendant. There was also real-world evidence of consumer confusion between the two businesses, which was helpful to FLOWERBX.
The decision reinforces the position that there is a spectrum of brand names which can provide protection to businesses. At one end are invented or arbitrary marks which have no descriptive relationship with the relevant product. At the other end are terms which simply describe the product or its characteristics. In between are suggestive brands which allude to a product or service without necessarily describing it directly.
That middle ground can be commercially attractive. A suggestive brand can immediately communicate something to consumers while remaining capable of trade mark protection and successful enforcement. The trade-off is that there is likely to be some uncertainty over how far the resulting rights extend and where the line is drawn.
Five questions to ask when choosing a brand name
- Does the name describe the product or one of its characteristics? The more descriptive, the greater the potential difficulty in securing exclusive rights.
- Where does the name’s distinctiveness come from? If it derives mainly from a different spelling of an ordinary descriptive word, protection may be narrow.
- What will the business actually sell? The goods and services covered by the application should be considered carefully against current activities and realistic expansion plans.
- What is already in the market? Clearance searches before launch can identify earlier registered rights and other unregistered brands in the market who could prove problematic.
- Could you enforce it? Consider if the trade mark registration would give the business a clear basis for stopping a competitor using a similar name in a few years’ time?
Think about enforcement at the outset
The lesson from FLOWERBX is not that businesses should avoid suggestive brands. The case is an example of rights in a suggestive brand being successfully asserted and enforced.
Businesses should consider legal strength alongside marketing appeal when developing a new brand. Rather than asking “can we register this?”, the better question is “if someone adopts something similar in future, how easy will this brand be to enforce?”
Print article